RCL Exclusive

Madame Morbid’s Top 5 Haunted Places in New York City

The ghost-tour operator details the dark and ghoulish history of the Big Apple.

Adventure By

There’s a solid chance if you’re reading this in New York City that you’re standing over a dead body. It’s true! New York is almost 400 years old and before this place was the metropolis it is today, it was basically one big dumping ground for the deceased. Folks died a lot back then, so they needed a lot of burial spots. Ever notice those curved “decoration” walls in old apartment buildings? Well, those are called “coffin corners.” Before they were decorated with flowers and picture frames, they were used to help transport coffins up and down the stairs of apartments. Don’t believe me? Here are some places you might not know have a disturbing past …

Hangman's Elm tre
Hangman’s Elm tree in Central Park (wikimedia commons)

Hangman’s Elm

This 350-year-old tree is considered to be the area’s “oldest living resident” (as well as the oldest known tree in all of Manhattan). Public hangings took place here, and the park’s ground was once an old potter’s field, which still holds hundreds of thousands of dead bodies!

The Dakota
The Dakota is one of the earliest apartment buildings on Central Park West in New York City, circa 1890. (Library of Congress)

The Dakota

The film Rosemary’s Baby was shot in this building and John Lennon was assassinated here as well. While he was alive, he claimed to see a spirit he called the “Crying Lady Ghost.” Fun Fact: $30,000 dollars is rumored to be buried under his and Yoko Ono’s apartment.

Kreischer House
Kreischer House in Staten Island, New York. (Wikimedia Commons)

Kreischer House

Built in the late 1800s, this private home has seen many deaths. In 1894, the owner committed suicide and in 2005, the building’s caretaker (who was also a hit-man for the mob), murdered a man in the home and then burned his body in the basement. Good news, though. It’s currently for sale!

One if by land. Two if by sea. One if by land. Two if by sea.
One if by land. Two if by sea. (Oneifbyland.com)

One If By Land, Two If By Sea

Originally built as a carriage house for Aaron Burr, this building is now home to be one of the most romantic restaurants in the city. Aaron Burr’s daughter, Theodosia, is said to still haunt the place, and is known to take off women’s earrings from time to time. Another ghost is that of a woman in all black, who is said to have broken her neck when she fell down the stairs.

Most Holy Trinity Church
Most Holy Trinity Church, Brooklyn, New York. (wikimedia commons)

Most Holy Trinity Church

Built in the 1880s, mysterious tunnels and hallways lead throughout the church, and are said to only be accessible via a priest. The original pastor died in his second floor room and a man was bludgeoned to death by 2 men robbing the poor box in 1897. His bloody handprint can still be seen from time to time in the bell tower.

Allison Huntington Chase is the CEO of Madame Morbid’s Trolly Tours, Brooklyn’s only year-round trolley tour that specializes in ghost stories and dark history.